Poor Tim Urban, as per the AP, his chance to show the judges what he can do didn’t go over too well. The 20 year old was chosen to replace Chris Golightly after it was found out Golightly had a previous record deal. However, his take on “Apologize” was not well received, though to be fair, he was not alone.
Man, that must really suck. You are given a second chance, and then it doesn’t go over well. It is up to the public though, so anything can still happen (Sanjaya anyone?)